How Does Missouri’s Comparative Fault Rule Affect Your Injury Claim?

You’re going about nine over the speed limit down Olive when a pickup truck rolls out of a gas station lot and crushes your front fender. Two days later, with your arm in a sling, the other driver’s insurance adjuster calls to say the crash looks to be about 40% your doing.

That number matters.

Under Missouri’s comparative fault law, your compensation is cut by whatever share of the blame lands on you.

It doesn’t end your claim, though plenty of injured people assume it does and take a lowball check. Others don’t realize the adjuster’s percentage is an opening position that a St. Louis personal injury lawyer can contest.

Even at 90% to Blame, You Still Have a Claim.

Pure comparative fault means a jury divides 100% of the blame among the parties in the lawsuit, and each person’s damages shrink by their own share.

The Missouri Supreme Court adopted the rule in 1983. It replaced the old doctrine of contributory negligence, under which a driver who was 1% careless could be sent home with nothing. Now there is no cutoff. If a jury pinned 90% of that Olive crash on you, you could still collect 10% of your losses from the pickup driver’s insurer.

Once you cross the Poplar Street Bridge, the rule gets less forgiving. Illinois uses a modified version, and the statute there bars you from recovering anything once your share of fault exceeds 50%. A 51% finding in a Belleville courtroom leaves you with nothing, while the same finding in St. Louis leaves you with 49% of your damages.

Where the crash happened usually decides which state’s rule applies, so the side of the river you were on does matter.

What a 25% Share Does to a $100,000 Verdict

Say a St. Louis jury hears your case and awards you $100,000. Of that total, $40,000 covers your surgery bills and the paychecks you missed, and $60,000 is for the pain and the three months you couldn’t pick up your daughter. The jury also decides that the speeding made you 25% responsible.

Here is how the reduction works:

  • Total damages: $100,000
  • Your share of the fault: 25%
  • Reduction: $25,000
  • What you collect: $75,000

The cut comes off the whole award, so your hospital bills take the same 25% reduction as your pain and suffering.

At 80% of fault, you would collect $20,000 in Missouri and nothing in Illinois.

On a claim that size, every point of blame the pickup driver’s insurance can shift onto you saves the company $1,000, and reducing damages by fault costs an insurer far less effort than denying the claim outright.

Where the Adjuster’s 40% Comes From

Long before a jury gets involved, the adjuster for the pickup driver’s insurer settles on a percentage of their own. They read the police report, listen to both drivers’ recorded statements, and then they pick a figure. No formula produces it. The adjuster isn’t trying to cheat you, but the company pays less for every point of fault that lands on you.

So, the nine-over-the-speed-limit in the crash report becomes 40% in the file, and the “I didn’t see him until the last second” you said on a recorded call comes back during insurance settlement negotiations.

Some of what gets held against you carries less weight than you might think.

Take your seat belt. In a crash between two Missouri drivers, state law says an unbuckled belt can’t be counted as comparative fault at all. The most it can do is trim your damages by 1%, and only after an expert shows the belt would have changed your injuries.

The adjuster’s 40% is the insurance company’s negotiating position, and nothing in Missouri law requires you to accept it.

The Evidence That Moves Your Percentage

A fault percentage changes when somebody produces proof. In your Olive crash, that could be footage from the gas station’s security camera showing the pickup never stopping at the edge of the lot or dashcam video from the car behind you. It could be a witness who watched the other driver looking down at his phone.

Skid marks, crush damage, and the data recorder in each vehicle let an accident reconstruction engineer work out how fast you were both going and whether your extra nine miles per hour over the limit changed the outcome at all.

Most of that evidence has a short life. A store’s camera system overwrites old footage, and a totaled pickup gets sold for salvage with its data recorder still inside.

Photograph everything, write down what you remember this week, and ask the tow yard to hold your car. You are also under no obligation to give the other driver’s insurer a recorded statement, so hold off on that call until you’ve gotten advice.

Don’t Sign Off on the First Number

A share of the blame shrinks an injury claim in Missouri but doesn’t end it, and the size of that share stays open to argument until you either sign a settlement or a jury decides. Casey & Devoti opened in St. Louis in 1983, the same year the state adopted this rule, and our firm has represented injured people in eastern Missouri and southern Illinois for more than four decades.

If an adjuster has put a number on your share of the blame, reach out to our firm for a free consultation before you agree to it, and we’ll tell you whether that percentage holds up.

Firm News

As Missouri personal injury attorneys, we encourage you to subscribe and keep in touch with us for all the latest insights.

FAQ

Have questions about the process, your case, or what to expect next? Visit our FAQ page for clear answers and practical guidance before you reach out.

Practice Areas

Serving clients across Missouri and Illinois from their St. Louis office, Casey & Devoti handles serious personal injury, medical malpractice, automotive crash, and workers’ compensation cases with focused experience and individualized attention.

Our team is ready to assist you.

Request a Free Consultation

Serving clients across Missouri and Illinois from their St. Louis office, Casey & Devoti handles serious personal injury, medical malpractice, automotive crash, and workers’ compensation cases with focused experience and individualized attention.