Call us at 314-421-0763 Visit Casey & Devoti on Facebook Follow Casey & Devoti on Twitter Join Casey & Devoti on Google+ Find Casey & Devoti on LinkedIn

Medical Journal Study Criticizes Claim of Link between Malpractice Crisis and Litigation

Posted by Matthew J. Devoti on March 26, 2013

A study recently published in a prominent medical journal calls into question the claim that the existing “medical malpractice crisis” is a result of patients seeking redress for harm caused to them by their health care providers. The article, titled “Five Myths of Medical Malpractice” and published in the journal “Chest”, discounts five myths that proponents of tort reform commonly use to justify limiting the rights of injured patients and their families, including the notion that malpractice crises are spurred by spikes in medical malpractice litigation.

In their paper, the authors – Dr. David Hyman and Charles Silver – point to data from the National Practitioner Databank demonstrating that the frequency of paid medical practice claims per physician has steadily dropped since 1992 and is now less than one-half the level it was at that time. The authors also point to data demonstrating that “payout per physician” is 46% below the 1992 level. Dr. Hyman and Mr. Silver remark that so-called “reforms” enacted by states over the last twenty years have made it more difficult for injured patients to seek relief and that the cost of both prosecuting and defending claims has tremendously increased since 1988. For instance, the authors note, costs are increased by limitations put on the claims by state legislatures on who can serve as an expert because “decreased supply [of potential expert witnesses] translates into higher prices”.

In conclusion, Dr. Hyman and Mr. Silver state that: “The best reforms are patient safety initiatives that reduce the frequency and severity of medical mistakes.”

To read a copy of “Five Myths of Medical Malpractice,” click here.


What is Repetitive Stress Injury?

Oftentimes we associate a workplace injury with a single, catastrophic event such as an explosion or fall from a height.  However, most workplace injuries develop slowly, over time from the cumulative effect of repetitive movements or postures on the job.  These can include a wide  range of movements, such as keyboarding, hammering nails or holding […] more

Winter Driving Safety Tips

Earlier this week, the winter switch was flipped in the St. Louis region.  The winter snow storm on Monday left a wake of traffic congestion and accidents across the metro area.  While the official snowfall total was only 1.5 inches in St. Louis, it wreaked havoc on area roads causing 203 crashes and injuring 17 […] more

Firm Client Receives Favorable Appellate Court Ruling

The Missouri Court of Appeals issued an opinion earlier this week in favor of Casey, Devoti & Brockland client, Peter Dittrich. Dittrich was injured in a motor vehicle collision on February 2015, when the Jeep Liberty he was driving was struck by a trash truck in Jefferson County.  The crash happened on Missouri Highway 30 […] more

Super Lawyers
Missouri Bar Association
The Injury Board
Missouri Association of Trial Attorneys
Find a Lawyer
American Association for Justice